Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints

Emma C. Robinson, Kara Garcia, Matthew F. Glasser, Zhengdao Chen, Timothy S. Coalson, Antonios Makropoulos, Jelena Bozek, Robert Wright, Andreas Schuh, Matthew Webster, Jana Hutter, Anthony Price, Lucilio Cordero Grande, Emer Hughes, Nora Tusor, Philip V. Bayly, David C. Van Essen, Stephen M. Smith, A. David Edwards, Joseph Hajnal & 3 others Mark Jenkinson, Ben Glocker, Daniel Rueckert

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In brain imaging, accurate alignment of cortical surfaces is fundamental to the statistical sensitivity and spatial localisation of group studies, and cortical surface-based alignment has generally been accepted to be superior to volume-based approaches at aligning cortical areas. However, human subjects have considerable variation in cortical folding, and in the location of functional areas relative to these folds. This makes alignment of cortical areas a challenging problem. The Multimodal Surface Matching (MSM) tool is a flexible, spherical registration approach that enables accurate registration of surfaces based on a variety of different features. Using MSM, we have previously shown that driving cross-subject surface alignment, using areal features, such as resting state-networks and myelin maps, improves group task fMRI statistics and map sharpness. However, the initial implementation of MSM's regularisation function did not penalize all forms of surface distortion evenly. In some cases, this allowed peak distortions to exceed neurobiologically plausible limits, unless regularisation strength was increased to a level which prevented the algorithm from fully maximizing surface alignment. Here we propose and implement a new regularisation penalty, derived from physically relevant equations of strain (deformation) energy, and demonstrate that its use leads to improved and more robust alignment of multimodal imaging data. In addition, since spherical warps incorporate projection distortions that are unavoidable when mapping from a convoluted cortical surface to the sphere, we also propose constraints that enforce smooth deformation of cortical anatomies. We test the impact of this approach for longitudinal modelling of cortical development for neonates (born between 31 and 43 weeks of post-menstrual age) and demonstrate that the proposed method increases the biological interpretability of the distortion fields and improves the statistical significance of population-based analysis relative to other spherical methods.

LanguageEnglish
Pages453-465
Number of pages13
JournalNeuroImage
Volume167
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Feb 2018

Keywords

  • Biomechanical priors
  • Discrete optimisation
  • Longitudinal registration
  • Neonatal brain development
  • Surface-based cortical registration

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neurology
  • Cognitive Neuroscience

Cite this

Robinson, E. C., Garcia, K., Glasser, M. F., Chen, Z., Coalson, T. S., Makropoulos, A., ... Rueckert, D. (2018). Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints. NeuroImage, 167, 453-465. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037
Robinson, Emma C. ; Garcia, Kara ; Glasser, Matthew F. ; Chen, Zhengdao ; Coalson, Timothy S. ; Makropoulos, Antonios ; Bozek, Jelena ; Wright, Robert ; Schuh, Andreas ; Webster, Matthew ; Hutter, Jana ; Price, Anthony ; Cordero Grande, Lucilio ; Hughes, Emer ; Tusor, Nora ; Bayly, Philip V. ; Van Essen, David C. ; Smith, Stephen M. ; Edwards, A. David ; Hajnal, Joseph ; Jenkinson, Mark ; Glocker, Ben ; Rueckert, Daniel. / Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints. In: NeuroImage. 2018 ; Vol. 167. pp. 453-465.
@article{26dbb1d5a2d843bc9baf865754583bc9,
title = "Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints",
abstract = "In brain imaging, accurate alignment of cortical surfaces is fundamental to the statistical sensitivity and spatial localisation of group studies, and cortical surface-based alignment has generally been accepted to be superior to volume-based approaches at aligning cortical areas. However, human subjects have considerable variation in cortical folding, and in the location of functional areas relative to these folds. This makes alignment of cortical areas a challenging problem. The Multimodal Surface Matching (MSM) tool is a flexible, spherical registration approach that enables accurate registration of surfaces based on a variety of different features. Using MSM, we have previously shown that driving cross-subject surface alignment, using areal features, such as resting state-networks and myelin maps, improves group task fMRI statistics and map sharpness. However, the initial implementation of MSM's regularisation function did not penalize all forms of surface distortion evenly. In some cases, this allowed peak distortions to exceed neurobiologically plausible limits, unless regularisation strength was increased to a level which prevented the algorithm from fully maximizing surface alignment. Here we propose and implement a new regularisation penalty, derived from physically relevant equations of strain (deformation) energy, and demonstrate that its use leads to improved and more robust alignment of multimodal imaging data. In addition, since spherical warps incorporate projection distortions that are unavoidable when mapping from a convoluted cortical surface to the sphere, we also propose constraints that enforce smooth deformation of cortical anatomies. We test the impact of this approach for longitudinal modelling of cortical development for neonates (born between 31 and 43 weeks of post-menstrual age) and demonstrate that the proposed method increases the biological interpretability of the distortion fields and improves the statistical significance of population-based analysis relative to other spherical methods.",
keywords = "Biomechanical priors, Discrete optimisation, Longitudinal registration, Neonatal brain development, Surface-based cortical registration",
author = "Robinson, {Emma C.} and Kara Garcia and Glasser, {Matthew F.} and Zhengdao Chen and Coalson, {Timothy S.} and Antonios Makropoulos and Jelena Bozek and Robert Wright and Andreas Schuh and Matthew Webster and Jana Hutter and Anthony Price and {Cordero Grande}, Lucilio and Emer Hughes and Nora Tusor and Bayly, {Philip V.} and {Van Essen}, {David C.} and Smith, {Stephen M.} and Edwards, {A. David} and Joseph Hajnal and Mark Jenkinson and Ben Glocker and Daniel Rueckert",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037",
language = "English",
volume = "167",
pages = "453--465",
journal = "NeuroImage",
issn = "1053-8119",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",

}

Robinson, EC, Garcia, K, Glasser, MF, Chen, Z, Coalson, TS, Makropoulos, A, Bozek, J, Wright, R, Schuh, A, Webster, M, Hutter, J, Price, A, Cordero Grande, L, Hughes, E, Tusor, N, Bayly, PV, Van Essen, DC, Smith, SM, Edwards, AD, Hajnal, J, Jenkinson, M, Glocker, B & Rueckert, D 2018, 'Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints', NeuroImage, vol. 167, pp. 453-465. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037

Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints. / Robinson, Emma C.; Garcia, Kara; Glasser, Matthew F.; Chen, Zhengdao; Coalson, Timothy S.; Makropoulos, Antonios; Bozek, Jelena; Wright, Robert; Schuh, Andreas; Webster, Matthew; Hutter, Jana; Price, Anthony; Cordero Grande, Lucilio; Hughes, Emer; Tusor, Nora; Bayly, Philip V.; Van Essen, David C.; Smith, Stephen M.; Edwards, A. David; Hajnal, Joseph; Jenkinson, Mark; Glocker, Ben; Rueckert, Daniel.

In: NeuroImage, Vol. 167, 15.02.2018, p. 453-465.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints

AU - Robinson, Emma C.

AU - Garcia, Kara

AU - Glasser, Matthew F.

AU - Chen, Zhengdao

AU - Coalson, Timothy S.

AU - Makropoulos, Antonios

AU - Bozek, Jelena

AU - Wright, Robert

AU - Schuh, Andreas

AU - Webster, Matthew

AU - Hutter, Jana

AU - Price, Anthony

AU - Cordero Grande, Lucilio

AU - Hughes, Emer

AU - Tusor, Nora

AU - Bayly, Philip V.

AU - Van Essen, David C.

AU - Smith, Stephen M.

AU - Edwards, A. David

AU - Hajnal, Joseph

AU - Jenkinson, Mark

AU - Glocker, Ben

AU - Rueckert, Daniel

PY - 2018/2/15

Y1 - 2018/2/15

N2 - In brain imaging, accurate alignment of cortical surfaces is fundamental to the statistical sensitivity and spatial localisation of group studies, and cortical surface-based alignment has generally been accepted to be superior to volume-based approaches at aligning cortical areas. However, human subjects have considerable variation in cortical folding, and in the location of functional areas relative to these folds. This makes alignment of cortical areas a challenging problem. The Multimodal Surface Matching (MSM) tool is a flexible, spherical registration approach that enables accurate registration of surfaces based on a variety of different features. Using MSM, we have previously shown that driving cross-subject surface alignment, using areal features, such as resting state-networks and myelin maps, improves group task fMRI statistics and map sharpness. However, the initial implementation of MSM's regularisation function did not penalize all forms of surface distortion evenly. In some cases, this allowed peak distortions to exceed neurobiologically plausible limits, unless regularisation strength was increased to a level which prevented the algorithm from fully maximizing surface alignment. Here we propose and implement a new regularisation penalty, derived from physically relevant equations of strain (deformation) energy, and demonstrate that its use leads to improved and more robust alignment of multimodal imaging data. In addition, since spherical warps incorporate projection distortions that are unavoidable when mapping from a convoluted cortical surface to the sphere, we also propose constraints that enforce smooth deformation of cortical anatomies. We test the impact of this approach for longitudinal modelling of cortical development for neonates (born between 31 and 43 weeks of post-menstrual age) and demonstrate that the proposed method increases the biological interpretability of the distortion fields and improves the statistical significance of population-based analysis relative to other spherical methods.

AB - In brain imaging, accurate alignment of cortical surfaces is fundamental to the statistical sensitivity and spatial localisation of group studies, and cortical surface-based alignment has generally been accepted to be superior to volume-based approaches at aligning cortical areas. However, human subjects have considerable variation in cortical folding, and in the location of functional areas relative to these folds. This makes alignment of cortical areas a challenging problem. The Multimodal Surface Matching (MSM) tool is a flexible, spherical registration approach that enables accurate registration of surfaces based on a variety of different features. Using MSM, we have previously shown that driving cross-subject surface alignment, using areal features, such as resting state-networks and myelin maps, improves group task fMRI statistics and map sharpness. However, the initial implementation of MSM's regularisation function did not penalize all forms of surface distortion evenly. In some cases, this allowed peak distortions to exceed neurobiologically plausible limits, unless regularisation strength was increased to a level which prevented the algorithm from fully maximizing surface alignment. Here we propose and implement a new regularisation penalty, derived from physically relevant equations of strain (deformation) energy, and demonstrate that its use leads to improved and more robust alignment of multimodal imaging data. In addition, since spherical warps incorporate projection distortions that are unavoidable when mapping from a convoluted cortical surface to the sphere, we also propose constraints that enforce smooth deformation of cortical anatomies. We test the impact of this approach for longitudinal modelling of cortical development for neonates (born between 31 and 43 weeks of post-menstrual age) and demonstrate that the proposed method increases the biological interpretability of the distortion fields and improves the statistical significance of population-based analysis relative to other spherical methods.

KW - Biomechanical priors

KW - Discrete optimisation

KW - Longitudinal registration

KW - Neonatal brain development

KW - Surface-based cortical registration

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85039714022&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037

DO - 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037

M3 - Article

VL - 167

SP - 453

EP - 465

JO - NeuroImage

T2 - NeuroImage

JF - NeuroImage

SN - 1053-8119

ER -

Robinson EC, Garcia K, Glasser MF, Chen Z, Coalson TS, Makropoulos A et al. Multimodal surface matching with higher-order smoothness constraints. NeuroImage. 2018 Feb 15;167:453-465. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.10.037